The Stories We Tell About Students
As we talked, I reminded him of things he had accomplished that he had almost forgotten: his discipline in the classroom, the leadership he showed with teammates, and the determination he brought to difficult moments. He was a champion on and off the field. Listening to him reflect on those memories reminded me of something every educator should consider:
Schools tell stories about students every day.
Some stories inspire belief. Others limit possibility. Either way, those stories shape how students see themselves and how others see them too.
That conversation stayed with me when I recently met with a group of five students participating in an action research project through a state university. When we first sat down together, they were frustrated. They felt like their project lacked direction and weren’t sure how to move forward. As we talked through their work, however, a different story began to emerge. Their project didn’t lack purpose; it reflected perseverance. These students were trying to solve real problems for their classmates, and their willingness to keep working through uncertainty said more about their character than any polished presentation ever could.
By the end of our conversation, the students hadn’t completely redesigned their project. They simply adjusted their approach and walked away with renewed clarity. What changed most wasn’t the project itself, but the narrative surrounding it.
Too often, educators unintentionally fall into deficit narratives. Phrases like “these kids just don’t care” or “they lack motivation” surface in moments of frustration. While those comments may reflect real challenges, they can also quietly shape expectations and beliefs about what students are capable of becoming. When those narratives take hold, struggle begins to define identity.
Changing the story does not mean ignoring reality. Students face real obstacles, and schools work through complex challenges every day. However, telling strength-based stories ensures that struggle does not become the final chapter. It allows us to recognize perseverance, growth, creativity, and leadership that might otherwise go unnoticed.
Years ago, the rise of social media and other digital tools gave schools new ways to share student accomplishments in real time. Educators began posting photos of robotics competitions, performances, service projects, and classroom achievements. These moments helped reshape the public narrative about schools by showing what students were capable of accomplishing every day. In many ways, those stories reminded communities that schools are places of opportunity, growth, and possibility.
In today’s climate, when public trust in institutions often feels fragile, the stories we tell about students matter more than ever. Schools are often criticized during difficult social or economic moments, and those criticisms can overshadow the incredible work happening in classrooms, labs, gyms, and studios across the country.
That’s why educators must be intentional about the narratives we share.
Every school has students whose stories reflect resilience, curiosity, kindness, and determination. These stories don’t deny the challenges students face; they highlight the strengths students bring with them. When we tell those stories, whether in conversations with colleagues, families, or community members, we reinforce a simple but powerful belief: our students are capable of more than the labels sometimes placed on them.
The question for us is simple:
What stories are we telling about our students?
Because those stories have a way of lasting much longer than we might imagine.



